Journal of Co-operative Studies 55(1), 134-147
The ‘mutualisation’ of public services in Britain: A critical commentary
| Open access |  | Editorial reviewed/Reprint article | Published online: Dec 2023 |
The ‘mutualisation’ of public services in Britain: A critical commentary.
Johnston Birchall
Journal of Co-operative Studies 55(1), 134-147
Orginally published in Journal of Co-operative Studies, 41(2), 2008, 5-16
https://doi.org/10.61869/IYGV4560
How to cite this paper: Birchall, J. (2022). The ‘mutualisation’ of public services in Britain: A critical commentary. Journal of Co-operative Studies, 55(1), 134-147. https://doi.org/10.61869/IYGV4560 (Original work published 2010).
Abstract
This article provides a critical commentary on the ‘new mutualism’, an intellectual current in the recent debate about public services in Britain that argues for the ‘mutualisation’ of service delivery agencies. First, it defines a mutual, and identifies important ways in which the new mutuals diverge from this definition. It traces the genesis of the idea in the ‘old mutualism’ of pre-welfare state Britain, explaining how mutuals were rejected in the setting up of the post-war welfare state. It describes how foundation hospitals and other recent developments have been influenced by a new appreciation of the idea of mutuality that has been used to help shape New Labour’s modernisation of public services. It shows how mutuals fit with other new forms such as the public interest company and social enterprise, and with a broader ‘script’ provided by communitarianism and the ‘third way’. It considers potential weaknesses in the argument, and then reviews criticisms concerning inequality and lack of participation. Finally, it asks whether the concept will remain as influential in the future, and whether it will deliver the improvements in public services that its advocates have promised.
PDF
References
Atkinson, D. (1994). The common sense of community. Demos.
Bentley, T. (2000). Foreword. In Etzioni, A. The third way to a good society (pp. 7-10). Demos.
Beveridge, W. (1948). Voluntary Action. Allen and Unwin.
Beveridge, W., & Wells, A. (1949). The evidence for voluntary action. Allen and Unwin.
Birchall, J. (1988). Building communities: The co-operative way. Routledge.
Birchall, J. (1997). The international co-operative movement. Manchester University Press.
Birchall, J. (2000). Some theoretical and practical implications of the attempted takeover of a consumer co-operative society. Annals of Public and Cooperative Economics, 71(1), 29-54. https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-8292.00132
Birchall, J. (Ed.). (2001). The new mutualism in public policy. Routledge.
Birchall, J. (2004). The mutualisation of public services in Britain: A critical commentary. Kurswechsel, 3, 85-95.
Birchall, J. (2005a). Business ethics and the Co-operative Bank. In C. Tsuzuki (Ed.). The emergence of global citizenship: Utopian ideas, co-operative movements and the third sector. Robert Owen Association of Japan.
Birchall, J. (2005b) Co-operative principles ten years on. Review of International Co-operation, 98(2), 45-63.
Birchall, J. (2005c, March). Democracy in the NHS? PPI Monitor.
Birchall, J., & Simmons, R. (2004). User power: The participation of users in public services. NationalConsumer Council.
Birchall, J., & Simmons, R. (2005, February). What motivates patients and the public to get involved in health care? PPI Monitor.
Blair, T. (2004, January 29). The prime minister's speech at the Guardian's public services summit today [full text). The Guardian.
Blears, H. (2002). Mutualism and the development of the National Health Service. In S. Hogan (Ed.). Making Healthcare Mutual: a publicly funded, locally accountable NHS. Mutuo.
Brecher, C. (2002). The Public Interest Company as a mechanism to improve service delivery: Suggestions for the reorganisation of the London Underground and National Health Service Trusts. Public Management Foundation.
Cabinet Office (2006). The UK government’s approach to public service reform — a discussion paper. Prime Minister’s Strategy Unit, Public Service Reform Team [The National Archives]. https://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/webarchive/
Crisp, N., & Linnett, N. (1995). The mutualisation of the NHS (Unpublished discussion paper).
Department of Health (2003). A Short Guide to NHS Foundation Trusts. https://www.nuffieldtrust.org.uk/files/2019-11/foundation.pdf
Department of Trade and Industry [DTI]. (2002). Social enterprises: A strategy for success. DTI. [The National Archives]. https://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/webarchive/
Drake, L., & Llewellyn, D. (2001). The economics of mutuality: a perspective on building societies. In J. Birchall (Ed.). The New mutualism in public policy, (pp. 14-40). Routledge.
Etzioni, A. (1996). The new Golden Rule: Community and morality in a democratic society. Basic Books.
Etzioni, A. (2000). The Third Way to a Good Society. Demos.
Field, F. (1996). Stakeholder welfare. Institute of Economic Affairs Health and Welfare Unit.
Giddens, A. (1998). The Third Way: The renewal of social democracy. Polity Press.
Giddens, A. (2000). The Third Way and its critics. Polity Press.
Giddens, A. (2002). Where now for New Labour? Polity Press.
Gorsky, M., Mohan, J., & Willis, T. (2005). From hospital contributory schemes to health cash plans: mutualism in British health care after 1948. Journal of Social Policy, 34(3), 447-467. http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/S004727940500886X
Green, D. G. (1993). Reinventing Civil Society: The discovery of welfare without politics. Civitas Choice of Welfare No. 17. Civitas: Institute for the Study of Civil Society.
Green, D. G., & Irvine, B. (2001). Health Care in France and Germany: Lessons for the UK. Civitas: Institute for the Study of Civil Society.
Halpern, D., Bates, C., Mulgan G., Beales, G., & Heathfield, A. (2004). Personal responsibility and changing behaviour: The state of knowledge and its implications for public policy. Cabinet Office, Prime Minister’s Strategy Unit. [The National Archives]. https://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/webarchive/
Hargreaves, I. (1999). New mutualism in from the cold. The co-operative revival and social exclusion. Co‑operative Party.
Hewitt, P. (2001). Foreword. In E. Mayo & H. Moore. (2001). The Mutual State: low local communities can run public services. New Economics Foundation.
Hirst, P. (1999). Associationalist welfare: A reply to Marc Stears. Economy and Society, 28(4), 590-597. https://doi.org/10.1080/03085149900000019
Hogan, S. (Ed.). (2002). Making Healthcare Mutual: a publicly funded, locally accountable NHS. Mutuo.
Hopkins, A. (2004). Making public services personal: A new compact for public services. The Independent Policy Commission on Public Services Report to the National Consumer Council. National Consumer Council.
Hunt, P. (2002). Introduction. In S. Hogan (Ed.). Making Healthcare Mutual: a publicly funded, locally accountable NHS. Mutuo.
Kellner, P. (1998). New Mutualism: The third way. Co-operative Party.
Klein, R. (2004). The first wave of NHS foundation trusts. Low turnout in elections sends a warning signal. [Editorial]. British Medical Journal, 328, 1332. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.328.7452.1332
Lea, R., & Mayo, E. (2002). The mutual health service: How to decentralise the NHS. Institute of Directors/New Economics Foundation.
Leadbeater, C. (2004). Personalisation through participation: A new script for public services. Demos.
Leadbeater, C., & Christie, I. (1999). To our mutual advantage. Demos.
Mabbett, D. (2001). Mutuality in insurance and social security: Retrospect and prospect. In J. Birchall (Ed.). The New Mutualism in Public Policy, (pp. 118-131). Routledge.
Mayo, E., & Moore, H. (2001). The Mutual State: low local communities can run public services. New Economics Foundation.
Milburn, A (2003, February 19). Localism: from rhetoric to reality. Speech to the New Local Government Network and Health Network. [Political Speech Archive]. https://www.ukpol.co.uk/alan-milburn-2003-speech-on-localism/
Mohan, J. (2003). Reconciling equity and choice? Foundation hospitals and the future of the NHS. A Catalyst Working Paper. Catalyst.
Parnell, E. (1995). Reinventing the co-operative: Enterprises for the twenty first century. Plunkett Foundation.
Pollitt, C., Birchall, J., & Putnam, K. (1998). Decentralising public service management. Macmillan.
Powell, M. (2000). New Labour and the third way in the British welfare state: A new and distinctive approach? Critical Social Policy, 20(1), 39-60. https://doi.org/10.1177/026101830002000103
Simmons, R., Birchall, J., Doheny, S., & Powell, M. (2007). Citizen governance: opportunities for inclusivity in policy and policy making? Policy & Politics, 35(3), 457-478. https://doi.org/10.1332/030557307781571551
Stears, M. (1999). Needs, welfare and the limits of associationalism. Economy and Society, 28(4), 570‑589. https://doi.org/10.1080/03085149900000018
White, S. (1998). Interpreting the Third Way: Not one route but many. Renewal, 6(1), 17-30.
White, S. (2001). The ambiguities of the Third Way. In S. White (Ed.). New Labour: The progressive future? (pp. 3-17). Palgrave Macmillan.
Whiteside, N. (1999). Private provision and public welfare: health insurance between the wars. In D. Gladstone (Ed.). Before Beveridge: Welfare Before the Welfare State. Civitas Choice in Welfare No. 47, (pp. 26-42). Civitas: Institute for the Study of Civil Society.
